Chapter 161 — Fuck! Even My Prisoners Have More Honor Than Me!
Loading Edge voices…
Garth’s answer settled over the Council Chamber, leaving a silence that felt very different from the one that had greeted his arrival. Earlier, everyone had been staring at a prisoner in chains, wondering why Nessara had brought him before us. Now I was looking at a commander who’d stayed behind to protect his soldiers while the dungeon he’d served collapsed around him.
The unfortunate part was that I understood him perfectly.
If someone invaded Ashfall tomorrow, I’d expect Seraphina to fight for our people. I’d fight beside her until my wings were torn and my mana exhausted. Yet Garth had done much the same thing for his home, and I’d kept him imprisoned afterward simply because he’d lost.
’Gods damn it. How am I supposed to maintain my reputation as a terrifying villainess when people insist on being so inconveniently honorable?’
Reika broke the silence first. She leaned forward, resting her muscular forearms against the table, her amber eyes fixed on Garth. "You knew your Dungeon Lord was losing, didn’t you? Your soldiers were outnumbered, and there was no guarantee you’d survive. Why not order them to surrender?"
Garth turned to face her, neither intimidated by her imposing horns nor eager to impress her. "Because surrender wasn’t possible for every position at once. We still had people behind us, and I needed time to get them somewhere safer. Once I knew we couldn’t hold, I ordered those who could withdraw to do so."
Reika studied him, her expression slowly changing. "So you didn’t fight simply because your pride wouldn’t let you lose?"
"Pride doesn’t bring dead soldiers home," he answered.
A rough laugh escaped her. She sat back, folding her arms, and the approval in her eyes was unmistakable. "Good. Too many commanders learn that lesson after they’ve buried half their people."
Before I could respond, Yumeha tilted her head, the delicate ornaments in her silver-white hair catching the light. "There’s another question here, Mistress. You offered each faction the opportunity to choose its own representative. The goblins and hobgoblins chose Garth despite knowing he was imprisoned. If we disregard that decision, what should the others believe about the freedom you’ve promised them?"
I gave her a pointed look. "That their Dungeon Lord would prefer candidates who don’t require armed escorts?"
Her golden eyes brightened with amusement, but she didn’t retreat. "A reasonable preference. Yet now that we’ve heard why they chose him, surely the question deserves a more serious answer."
Mavis adjusted one dark sleeve, the silver webbing across its fabric catching the light as she spoke. "It does, although I see a danger in the opposite direction. An election cannot become a means of escaping punishment. Otherwise, any offender with enough friends could demand a seat at this table."
That earned a measured nod from Rhazek. I glanced between the two women, appreciating the distinction they’d raised. Yumeha wanted the residents’ choices respected; Mavis wanted to ensure those choices never placed someone above the rules. Neither seemed interested in winning an argument merely for the pleasure of it.
’Wonderful. My government is already making sensible points. How am I supposed to complain about politicians now?’
"Then we should stop treating his election as evidence of innocence or guilt," Varkesh said. His deep voice carried across the table, drawing everyone’s attention. "We should judge what he did. Defending one’s own dungeon is not the same as marching into another to attack it. If Ashfall came under siege, would we condemn Seraphina for defending its gates?"
Seraphina’s blue eyes sharpened at the comparison. "No," she replied, stepping closer to the table. "But loyalty to a previous master doesn’t automatically become loyalty to a new one." She looked directly at Garth. "You followed orders even when you knew your Dungeon Lord failed your people. Why should Ashfall trust you now?"
Garth’s gaze shifted briefly toward the three witnesses who’d come with him. The smaller goblin was twisting his hands together so tightly that I thought he might injure himself, while the two hobgoblins stood rigidly beside him.
"My former Dungeon Lord is dead," Garth answered. "His rule ended when your Mistress conquered our home. I won’t pretend I welcomed it, but I’ve seen what life has become for my people here. They have food, shelter, and a chance to live without fearing the next order from a lord who doesn’t care whether they survive." He faced Seraphina again. "My loyalty has always been to the people entrusted to me. They’re here now."
Seraphina didn’t smile, although the tension around her mouth eased. "And if one of your former soldiers tried to harm Ashfall out of resentment?"
"I’d stop him," Garth said. "I’d rather restrain one fool than watch him drag the rest of us into another war."
Rhazek narrowed his eyes. "Even if that soldier had once fought beside you?"
"Especially then. He’d know I wasn’t speaking lightly."
A low murmur traveled around the table. Rhazek considered him for a moment before inclining his head, satisfied enough to let the matter rest. Seraphina returned to my side, but I could tell from her thoughtful expression that she hadn’t finished evaluating him. I doubted she’d ever stop evaluating someone who might one day command soldiers under her authority.
Brammok shifted in his reinforced chair, massive hands folded around his staff. "I’ve known leaders who called themselves honorable because they spoke well and carried fine weapons. Then trouble came, and the people depending on them were left behind." His copper-colored gaze settled on Garth. "These three came here to speak for you when doing so could have angered their new ruler. That says something about the trust you’ve earned."
The older hobgoblin lowered his eyes, visibly moved by the recognition. Garth looked uncomfortable enough that I almost pitied him. The man could face an enemy invasion without flinching, but several compliments might finish him off.
Isshara, who had listened with her hands resting against her emerald coils, turned toward Nessara. "I believe his people, but there is something we mustn’t forget. The Dark Elves suffered terribly in the former dungeon. Hearing that Garth wasn’t involved doesn’t make what happened to them any less serious. Have those accounts truly been examined?"
The warmth in her voice had given way to the steady firmness I’d heard when she questioned Brammok about his injured shoulder. She wasn’t accusing Garth; she was making certain the people who’d suffered wouldn’t disappear beneath everyone else’s admiration for him.
Nessara met her gaze. "They have. The testimonies gathered from the rescued Dark Elves do not identify Garth among their abusers. He was not part of the force that attacked Ashfall, and nothing we’ve established connects him to those crimes. He was taken prisoner while defending his dungeon." Her fingers rested lightly against the documents before her. "I won’t ask my people to forget what they endured. But neither will I hold this man responsible for what others did simply because they served the same Dungeon Lord."
I watched her closely. There was pain behind that composure, yet she hadn’t allowed it to distort her judgment. When she finished, Isshara inclined her head, and several of the representatives followed suit.
’Gods, Nessara. Could you please stop making me fall in love with you in the middle of official proceedings?’
Sable leaned toward me, her lavender hair brushing my shoulder. "Darling, if his imprisonment was never connected to a proven offense against Ashfall, isn’t that the question we ought to resolve before anything else?"
I looked at her, then at the restraints around Garth’s wrists.
There it was, painfully simple beneath all our careful arguments. His people weren’t demanding that an election erase his crimes. They were asking me to recognize a man who’d protected them, who hadn’t joined the attack against my dungeon, and who hadn’t participated in the horrors inflicted on the Dark Elves.
He was still standing in chains because he’d defended his home against me.
And I’d have done exactly the same thing in his place.
I rose from my chair, and conversation faded as I stepped down from the small dais. Garth straightened instinctively, watching me with an expression that revealed nothing of what he might be hoping for. The three witnesses stood close enough that I could see the goblin’s throat move as he swallowed.
"Garth, one final question. If I decide to keep you imprisoned, what will you tell the people who elected you?"
He glanced at the witnesses, and something painful passed through his face before he mastered it. "That they made their choice, Mistress, and you made yours. I’ll tell them to respect your decision. They finally have a home where their families can live safely, and I won’t let them risk losing it for my sake." His voice roughened, though his posture remained firm. "They asked me to speak for them, not start another war."
For a moment I could hear nothing but the faint rustle of banners overhead. He hadn’t begged, threatened, or tried to turn his people’s affection into a weapon. Even now, he was thinking about what would happen to them if his fate became a cause for resentment.
I sighed, then gave him a look of profound exasperation. "You know, you could’ve made this much easier by being a terrible person. I’d have had you escorted out, and we could’ve gotten on with the meeting."
A startled chuckle escaped the smaller goblin. Reika grinned, and even Garth looked briefly uncertain whether I was joking.
"But you’ve forced me to do something much more troublesome," I continued, letting the humor fade. "I’ve had to listen to evidence, consider an argument, and admit I was wrong about a prisoner. Absolutely scandalous behavior for a villainess."
Nessara’s mouth curved into the faintest smile. I turned back to Garth, meeting his eyes squarely.
"You defended your dungeon when I invaded it. You did not join the force that attacked Ashfall, and there is no evidence that you participated in the abuse of its Dark Elf prisoners. Your former Dungeon Lord’s crimes are not automatically yours. I have no just reason to keep you confined for fulfilling your duty to the people under your command."
He held his breath, his scarred face still as stone.
"As Mistress of Ashfall, I’m granting you a full pardon for your actions defending your former dungeon. You’re free, Garth. And I recognize your people’s choice to have you represent them here."
The smaller goblin made a strangled noise, clapping both hands over his mouth as the guards stepped forward to unlock Garth’s restraints. The cuffs dropped away with a metallic clink. Garth looked down, slowly flexing his freed fingers, while one hobgoblin clasped the other’s shoulder so tightly that I suspected he’d leave bruises.
"Mistress..." Garth’s voice was unsteady when he finally lifted his head. "I don’t know how to thank you."
"You can start by making certain your people never put me through another surprise election like this." My smile softened as relief spread across his face. "And don’t mistake this pardon for permission to let them down. They’ve trusted you when it wasn’t convenient. Make sure you deserve it."
He pressed a fist against his chest, standing as straight as he could. "I will, Mistress. You have my word."
Nessara approached the table with her ledger held neatly against her side. Her crimson eyes moved over the witnesses before she addressed Garth. "Then, on behalf of Ashfall’s administration, welcome as the elected representative of the goblins and hobgoblins. Please take your seat."
Garth hesitated, looking back at the companions who’d stood for him. The older hobgoblin nodded once, solemn and proud, while the goblin practically bounced on his heels. Only then did Garth cross the chamber to the waiting chair. Reika acknowledged him with a respectful tilt of her head, Brammok made room for him, and Rhazek watched without objection as he sat.
I returned to my own chair, taking in the completed circle of representatives. Nine factions, nine voices, and one newly freed commander whose people had refused to leave him behind. We’d not discussed a single department or passed one administrative decision, yet this gathering had already revealed something important about the sort of dungeon we were becoming.
I glanced toward Nessara, who opened her ledger and prepared to begin the meeting we’d originally assembled for. Around the table, the representatives settled themselves, their earlier unease replaced by cautious anticipation.
’Well, shit. That was one hell of an opening act.’