Skip to chapter text
NovelFerrySuccubus Evolution: Building My SSS-Rank Villainess Harem
← Succubus Evolution: Building My SSS-Rank Villainess HaremEnglish edition · Chapter 160

Chapter 160 — My Prisoner Has Better References Than Me?!

2,096 wordsEnglish

Contents

Loading Edge voices…

"Nessara, would you care to explain why one of my prisoners is standing in the middle of my Council Chamber in chains?"

I kept my voice pleasantly conversational, although the look I gave my beautiful administrator was considerably less innocent. Across the crescent-shaped table, nine chairs waited for the representatives of Ashfall’s different factions, yet the only person who seemed remotely comfortable with our unexpected visitor was the woman responsible for organizing this entire gathering.

Garth stood between two guards, his scarred face composed, while the two hobgoblins and the smaller goblin accompanying him watched me with an apprehension they were doing a rather poor job of concealing.

Nessara placed her documents on the table, smoothing one corner before answering. "Because, Mistress, the goblins and hobgoblins have unanimously selected Garth as their representative. Given his present circumstances, I believed it would be inappropriate to recognize their choice without bringing the matter before you."

I stared at her for a moment, hoping the explanation might become less ridiculous if I considered it carefully.

’Fantastic. My first election, and somebody’s already managed to nominate a prisoner. At this rate, I’ll have to build a separate prison wing for politicians.’

"And you couldn’t have mentioned this yesterday?" I asked, raising an eyebrow.

"I considered it, Mistress." Nessara’s expression remained composed, although the faint tension around her eyes betrayed her discomfort. "However, the three individuals accompanying him requested an opportunity to explain their decision personally. I thought it best that you hear their testimony before reaching a conclusion."

That earned her a thoughtful look. Nessara wasn’t the sort of woman who overlooked details, particularly when those details involved prisoners from the dungeon that had once held Dark Elves captive. If she’d arranged this little confrontation, she must have believed there was something worth hearing.

I leaned back, letting my gaze settle on Garth. His iron-gray hair was as untidy as I remembered, and the broken tusk protruding from his mouth gave his already intimidating features a particularly severe appearance. Yet there was no hostility in his eyes. He stood with his shoulders squared and his hands restrained before him, looking more like a soldier awaiting inspection than a criminal being dragged before his judge.

"All right," I said eventually. "I’ll hear them. But before anyone starts delivering passionate speeches about friendship and loyalty, I want to understand something. Why Garth? There are plenty of goblins and hobgoblins living freely inside Ashfall. Surely at least one of them could have represented your people without requiring an armed escort."

The older of the two hobgoblins took a step forward, then hesitated when one of the guards shifted beside Garth. I lifted a hand, signaling that he could speak.

"Because none of us wanted anyone else, Mistress."

His voice was rough and weathered, carrying the conviction of someone who’d rehearsed his words several times and still found them insufficient. He was a broad-shouldered veteran with a heavily scarred jaw, and although his armor was simple, the disciplined manner in which he stood immediately distinguished him from an ordinary laborer.

"Garth commanded us long before your people came to our dungeon," he continued. "He was strict, and he expected every soldier to do his duty. If someone neglected their watch or endangered another member of the company, he made certain they answered for it. But he never punished someone merely because they were weak, and he never expected us to endure something he wouldn’t endure himself."

I glanced toward Garth, curious whether he intended to respond. His expression barely changed, though the slight tightening of his jaw told me he wasn’t entirely comfortable hearing himself praised.

The hobgoblin continued before I could interrupt. "There were times when our former Dungeon Lord cared more about his own ambitions than the people serving him. Supplies would be held back, work would be demanded without proper rest, and those at the bottom were expected to endure whatever happened. Garth made certain his people were fed and that the injured received attention. Even when he couldn’t change an order, he did what he could to keep us from suffering under it."

"And everyone respected him for that?" I asked.

"Not everyone liked him," the veteran admitted, surprising me. "Some thought he was too stern. Others hated being disciplined. But even those soldiers trusted him when things went wrong, because he never abandoned his responsibilities."

That distinction caught my attention. It would have been easy to tell me Garth was universally beloved, some flawless hero whom everybody admired. Instead, the hobgoblin described someone demanding and occasionally unpopular, yet dependable when his people needed him.

’Well, that’s inconvenient. I was hoping the election would be easier to dismiss.’

"Very well," I said, resting an elbow against the arm of my chair. "I understand why you respected him as a commander. But that still doesn’t explain everything. Garth was captured when we defeated your former dungeon. What exactly was his involvement in the attack against Ashfall?"

The question changed the atmosphere. Reika, who had been listening with her muscular arms folded, straightened slightly, while Rhazek’s attention settled more firmly on the witnesses. Even Yumeha’s playful expression faded as she waited for the answer.

The second hobgoblin stepped forward. He was younger than the first, with dark hair tied behind his head and an old injury that left one shoulder sitting slightly lower than the other.

"He wasn’t part of the attacking force, Mistress," he replied. "Garth remained behind when the troops marched toward Ashfall. His orders were to maintain the dungeon’s defenses and command the soldiers who stayed."

I narrowed my eyes, searching through my memories of the Hobgoblin Lord’s defeat. There had been several commanders among the enemy defenders, and I remembered the fighting as we pushed through their territory. What I hadn’t done was investigate every captured soldier’s precise responsibilities afterward.

"So you’re telling me he never marched against us?"

"No, Mistress. He didn’t."

"And when my forces entered your dungeon?"

"He defended it," the hobgoblin answered without hesitation. His eyes flickered toward Garth before returning to mine. "He organized the defenders, held our positions, and tried to protect everyone who remained inside. We knew the situation was turning against us, but he refused to abandon his post while others were still depending on him."

I studied the younger soldier, waiting for him to soften the account or attempt to excuse the battle itself. Instead, he met my gaze with visible nervousness and continued speaking.

"We fought against you, Mistress. I won’t deny that, and neither will he. But we were defending the only home we knew. Garth didn’t send soldiers to raid Ashfall, and he wasn’t responsible for the orders that brought the fighting to your gates."

The words settled over the room, leaving me with a realization I didn’t particularly enjoy.

Garth hadn’t invaded my home. I’d invaded his.

Of course, I’d possessed excellent reasons for destroying the Hobgoblin Lord’s dungeon, and I certainly wasn’t about to apologize for removing that bastard from the world. But from Garth’s perspective, an enemy had entered the place he’d sworn to protect, and he’d responded exactly as any honorable commander would.

’Well, shit. That’s starting to sound awfully familiar.’

I glanced toward Seraphina, who stood a short distance from my chair. She had listened without interrupting, her blue eyes attentive and thoughtful. When our gazes met, she gave the slightest inclination of her head, confirming that she understood the distinction I’d just made.

Defending one’s home wasn’t the same as launching an attack against someone else’s.

Still, there was another matter I couldn’t overlook.

"And what about the Dark Elves?" I asked, turning back toward the witnesses. "Your former dungeon had prisoners who suffered terribly under its rule. Was Garth involved in any of that?"

The older hobgoblin’s face tightened, and for the first time, genuine shame entered his expression.

"No, Mistress. He wasn’t."

The younger soldier nodded. "He had no part in the abuse of those captives. That wasn’t the duty assigned to him, and he never participated in it."

Before either could elaborate, Nessara stepped forward, her expression grave.

"I’ve also examined that question, Mistress. The accounts gathered from the former captives do not identify Garth as one of their abusers, nor have we established that he participated in those crimes. His imprisonment has remained connected to his capture during the conquest, rather than any proven involvement in the treatment of the Dark Elves."

Her words carried considerable weight. Nessara was hardly someone who would dismiss what had happened to the captives, and I knew she understood the importance of distinguishing between those who had committed atrocities and those who had merely belonged to the same dungeon.

"Thank you," I replied quietly.

She inclined her head, and I turned toward the smaller goblin who had remained silent throughout the discussion.

He’d spent most of the hearing shifting nervously between the two larger warriors, occasionally glancing toward Garth as though searching for reassurance. His clothes were plain, his posture lacked their military discipline, and there was an almost comical contrast between his anxious expression and the stubborn determination with which he finally stepped forward.

"And you?" I asked, softening my voice. "What made you choose him?"

The goblin swallowed, glancing around the chamber before gathering his courage.

"Because he always remembered we were his people too, Mistress."

Something about the simplicity of his answer made me straighten.

"Explain."

He rubbed his palms against his trousers, clearly uncomfortable addressing so many imposing figures at once. "In our old dungeon, the hobgoblins were bigger and stronger. Some commanders cared about the warriors first, and the rest of us got whatever was left. Garth wasn’t like that. If somebody was hungry, he wanted to know why. If one of us was injured, he didn’t tell us to stop complaining and get back to work. He made sure someone helped."

His voice grew steadier as he spoke, encouraged by the fact that nobody had interrupted him.

"He wasn’t soft, Mistress. If we caused trouble, he’d scold us just as fiercely as anyone else. But he listened when we had a problem, and once he gave his word, we knew he’d keep it. When we were asked to choose a representative, the goblins and hobgoblins talked about it together. We could’ve chosen someone who was already free, but none of us thought that person would speak for everyone the way Garth would."

I watched Garth’s expression while the goblin spoke. His stern composure had begun to falter, not from fear but from the discomfort of hearing so many people openly acknowledge what he’d done for them.

"Did he ask you to elect him?" I asked.

The goblin shook his head vigorously. "No, Mistress. He told us to choose somebody else when he heard what we were planning. Said having a prisoner as our representative would only cause problems, and that we shouldn’t make trouble for ourselves on his account."

A faint murmur traveled around the table, and Yumeha leaned forward, studying Garth with renewed interest.

"But you refused?" she asked.

The goblin nodded. "We did. We told him that if the election meant anything, we should be allowed to choose the person we trusted most."

For a moment, I had no clever response.

I looked around the chamber, taking in the expressions of my assembled representatives. Reika’s eyes had narrowed thoughtfully, Brammok watched Garth with unmistakable respect, and Isshara’s gentle expression had become considerably more serious.

The three witnesses had described a commander who was stern, reliable, and willing to care for people his former Dungeon Lord had neglected. They weren’t asking me to overlook crimes he’d committed. They were asking me to recognize that he’d never committed the crimes I’d initially feared.

And yet he remained in chains.

I shifted my attention back toward Garth, who had listened to every word without offering a single argument in his own defense.

"One question," I said, leaning forward. "If you knew your Dungeon Lord was losing, why didn’t you surrender? Why remain behind and fight when you could have walked away?"

For the first time since entering the chamber, Garth raised his head fully and met my eyes.

There was no defiance in his expression, nor any attempt to disguise the simple conviction beneath his answer.

"Because they were still my people, Mistress," he replied, his deep voice carrying clearly through the silent chamber. "Whatever mistakes my Dungeon Lord made, the soldiers standing beside me deserved a commander who wouldn’t abandon them."

End of Chapter

Next chapter → Back to novel
Chapter discussion

Chapter discussion

No comments yet.

    Reading appearance

    Display

    Typography

    Text size19px

    Width adapts to your screen. Text stays at your chosen size.

    Audio & voice

    Voice and speed controls appear when the player opens.