Chapter 234 — Broken Father
Loading Edge voices…
"You don’t like hearing my plans," Alistair said accusingly.
Lillian smiled. "Yeah, because you are morally bankrupt."
He gave her a look. "It’s not winning me any awards lately." Alistair reached for her hand, threaded his fingers through hers and brought it to his lips. "Maybe I’ll retire to the country. Buy a farm."
Her eyes narrowed. "I know you are not giving up. You know where she is, don’t you?"
He didn’t bother pretending otherwise. "Yeah. I didn’t tell you because... well, you didn’t want to know."
"I still don’t." Lillian had made her position clear all those years ago. She had not wanted motherhood. She had not wanted to build her life around a child. And unlike most people, she had never had any interest in rewriting herself afterward just to appear softer. She looked at him steadily.
"He might find her without your help, you know. So you should place a bid on that farm in the country." Lillian added, "I’ll visit you twice a year."
He laughed. "Twice?"
"I’m being generous."
"Well, we’ll see how it goes."
The humour settled between them for a moment, but it didn’t erase the weight hanging over the room.
Alistair’s thumb brushed slowly over the back of her hand. "If you want to know about her, Lil..."
"No. No, there is no use. I made an informed decision to give her up. Am I supposed to feign regret now? My life is better for it." Lillian had never been interested in performing emotions other people believed she should have. "I have everything I worked for. My career. My name. My life. And I have you."
Lillian immediately ruined the moment. "I’m going to kill you later, just so you know."
Alistair chuckled. "Wouldn’t expect anything less."
Lillian rolled her eyes.
He rested his head against her thigh.
She looked down at him.
For all her anger, she let him stay there.
Alistair closed his eyes briefly and inhaled.
There were some things that had no explanations. Some situations that lacked common sense altogether.
Like a man falling in love with his nephew’s wife. Like that same man falling in love with a woman almost half his age.
Nothing about them had been simple. Nothing about them had been respectable. And absolutely nothing about their beginning would survive particularly well under moral examination.
Still, it had happened.
They had worked together.
Shared late nights preparing cases.
She had been sharp enough to challenge him, and ambitious enough to understand the parts of him other people found excessive.
Then somewhere along the way, it had become something else. Something neither of them had planned.
And perhaps that was the part Dorian had never been able to understand.
Dorian had loved Lillian deeply.
No one could deny that.
But in Alistair’s mind, Dorian had never had what it took to tame a woman like Lillian.
Dorian had wanted closeness.
A marriage built around emotional attachment and the certainty that they belonged to each other.
Lillian had wanted space to remain herself.
Dorian had been too soft.
Too emotional in all the places Lillian had learned to be hard.
Lillian needed steel without compromising her independence. She wanted to rule the world and yet be controlled privately.
It was one of the contradictions that made Lillian who she was.
In public, she wanted no one above her.
No one telling her what she could become, how far she could go, what she should sacrifice or which parts of herself were supposedly too much for a woman.
But in private, she wanted someone strong enough to meet her force with force. Someone who did not fear her ambition, did not mistake her independence for rejection and did not require her to become smaller so he could feel bigger.
With Alistair, she had bloomed.
She had owned exactly who she was without apology.
He had never asked her to become softer.
Never looked at her hunger for success like it was some character flaw that needed correcting. But it had come at a tremendous cost for both of them.
Lillian had given up a child.
Alistair had driven himself even farther away from his family, widening fractures that had already existed until some of them became almost impossible to cross.
They had hurt people. They had hurt Dorian.
No matter how Alistair justified the way things happened, there was no pretending otherwise. Would he do it again?
Absolutely.
Love rarely made respectable decisions. Love made fools of everyone. No matter who you were.
*****
By the time Dorian stood in front of his parents’ door, exhaustion had worked its way into every part of him.
He had spent hours chasing a girl he had not known existed the day before.
Anything that might give him one more thread to follow. Every dead end had felt like losing her all over again.
He barely remembered knocking.
The door opened, and Eleanor’s face lit up the instant she saw him.
"D—"
Then she really looked at him.
Her smile disappeared. "D?" she whispered.
Dorian tried to answer normally. He couldn’t. "Mum..." His voice broke.
Eleanor’s eyes widened.
Dorian stood there looking like a man who had been holding himself together with a thread and had finally reached the one place where he no longer knew how. "Mum..." he breathed again, and his heart seemed to break into tiny shards with the word. "I can’t find her. I can’t..."
"Who? Who? What’s going on?"
She pulled him into her arms and he let her. Her son was affectionate with her, yes, but Dorian Heathcliffe rarely collapsed into anyone.
He was usually the person other people collapsed into.
Eleanor held him tighter and turned her head toward the house. "Maurice!"
"I have been searching," Dorian said against her.
"For who?" Eleanor pulled back enough to look at him. "Naomi?"
The possibility clearly frightened her. Had something happened?
Dorian shook his head. "My daughter."
She stared at him as though she had misunderstood every word in the English language. "Who?"
Maurice appeared then. He had clearly heard Eleanor call him, but whatever question had been forming disappeared the moment he saw his son. He recognised it immediately.
Dorian was devastated.
"Get in," Maurice said at once.