Chapter 76 — Whoopsie Doopsie do!!!!!!!!
Loading Edge voices…
"Yeah, I figured you did," Ethan said, keeping his voice level. "The detective asked me a lot of questions yesterday. Where I was, what I heard, and how well I knew Teresa. Standard stuff."
"Standard?" Nicole’s eyes went wide. "Ethan, that doesn’t sound standard at all. That sounds like they think you did it."
(Come on, Nic. You’re smarter than that.)
"They think everyone did it right now. That’s how these things start." He tried for a tired half smile and didn’t quite manage it well enough. "But it’s definitely not a good look; it happened a few hours after I left her, apparently."
"And you have an alibi, right? For that night, I mean." She asked it softly, almost apologetically, and then winced at herself. "God, sorry. I know how that sounds. I’m just worried about you."
Ethan stared at her for a moment longer than usual; he couldn’t point out what was wrong with her today, but she was acting rather uncharacteristically.
"I was home," Ethan said.
It was only a small thing. Nicole’s smile didn’t slip, and her grip on his arm didn’t change, but something behind her eyes tightened for a fraction of a second, like a hand closing around a coin.
"Right," she said. "How did they know you were there? Did you just walk up to them and admit it? Because that would be...stupid."
"I didn’t walk up to anyone, actually," Ethan said. "Katherine already told them."
Nicole blinked. "Katherine? As in the school counselor Katherine? The principal?"
"The same. Teresa was one of her secretaries, so naturally there was an association. When the police asked who had been in contact with her recently, Katherine gave them my name." He shrugged, though it cost him more than he let show. "I can’t really blame her; you can’t go around these things."
"Can’t really blame her, huh?" Nicole repeated it slowly: "Ethan, that’s a very strange thing to just volunteer."
"Is it?"
"Of course it is. You don’t hand someone’s name to the police unless you have a reason." She sat up a little straighter and drew her hand back from his thigh, and he felt the warmth of it disappear. "Why would she even say that? And how did she know you were there at all? Were you with her when you went? Did she follow you, or did Teresa call her afterward?"
(What is she getting at here...)
"I told her I was going. That’s all."
"So she knew exactly where you’d be and exactly when, and the next thing anyone hears, Teresa is dead and the police have your name." Nicole lifted one eyebrow. "I’m not saying anything. I just think that’s fucking convenient."
He almost smiled, in spite of everything.
"Convenient for who?" he asked mildly.
"For her," Nicole said it as if it were obvious. "Think about it. Teresa worked under her. Katherine would know her schedule, her habits, and probably which days she was home alone. And she’s the one who sent you there, which puts you right in the middle of it." She picked up her mug again, and her fingers tightened around the handle. "If I were looking for someone to point at, that’s exactly how I’d do it."
(So quickly? She didn’t even consider if I was behind it.
"You’re saying Katherine killed Teresa and set me up."
"I’m just saying it doesn’t sound right! But what would I know?"
(I have to bring it up, don’t I?)
He lets out a sigh.
"What you don’t know, Nicole, is that they identified me through cum stains on Teresa’s bed."
"I’m sorry," she said slowly. "What?"
"The police found traces on the bed." He said, his eyes fixed on hers, "Katherine gave them my name, and the lab did the rest. So it isn’t just that I happened to be around. I’m probably the last person known to have been with her. And even if I wasn’t, my marks were all there for all to see—bad luck."
"You slept with her."
"Yeah."
"In her bed."
"Where do people fuc—"
"No, I’m just making sure I understand." She let out a short, brittle laugh and pressed the back of her wrist against her mouth. "Right. Of course. Of course you did. You fucked the secretary."
(Apparently she didn’t hear us...hm.)
"It always just happens with you, doesn’t it?"
He didn’t answer. There wasn’t much to say to that, and in any case, none of this mattered anymore, and he felt himself getting tired of the case.
"I heard you, you know." She said as she lit up a cigarette.
(Oh...so she did...hmmmm.)
"Yeah, Teresa told me there isn’t much of a sound barrier around these apartments."
"Would it have made a difference?"
"What do you mean?"
"You didn’t pass by, just saying."
He opened his mouth, then closed it again. She nodded as if he had answered, flicked her ash into the saucer under her mug, and finally turned her head to look at him. Her eyes were dry now, and her expression was so perfectly neutral that it didn’t feel neutral.
"Don’t look so worried," she said lightly. "I’m not upset. Why would I be? You’re a grown man, she was a grown woman, and it’s not as if you and I have any kind of arrangement. You can sleep with whoever you like."
"I know that."
"Good. Then we agree." She took another drag. "I’m just curious, that’s all. As a matter of pure curiosity."
"The secretary," she said, exhaling the smoke, "is Teresa. Out of everyone you could have picked, in this whole city, with all the options you apparently have. You went down one floor, to a woman who photocopied forms for a living, and you decided that was the best use of your afternoon."
(She is one rank higher than you, nic...was...)
"It wasn’t like that."
"Then what was it like?" She tilted her head, and her smile stayed exactly where it was. "Was she good? Was it worth it?"
"That’s not a fair question."
"It’s a perfectly fair question. You were there. I wasn’t, not in the way that counts." She tapped the cigarette against the saucer, and the ash scattered. "I only ask because I’d like to know what she had that made it worth all of this. She’s dead, rest in peace, and you’re sitting here as confused as I am. Why? Hm? It all started because you couldn’t walk past a desk without making a move. So I just want to understand. Was it worth it? Do you really have to think with your dick all the time, Ethan?"
The room went very quiet.
He wanted to say something sharp back. He wanted to point out that there was no way to predict any of this. But each of those answers dissolved the moment he put it into words. That’s the thing, isn’t it? It’s almost never worth arguing back with her.
"No," he said at last. "I guess not."
"No?" Nicole raised her eyebrows. "At least you are honest with yourself."
(whatever...)
"I think you probably feel quite terrible about it. Which makes sense, doesn’t it? If you had just stayed home or kept your hands to yourself, you wouldn’t have your name all over the case, but I guess we all make mistakes! Right!."
"Right," Ethan said quietly. Mostly curious to see the end of this.
"See? We agree again." Nicole smiled and took a last drag from her cigarette before stubbing it out in the saucer. "I’m just looking out for you; I can’t leave my bestie doing stupid decisions, right?"
(Sure.)
She leaned back against the couch and stretched, slowly, with her arms lifted over her head and her back arching a little. The sweater rode up with the motion, and it kept riding. It stopped only when the undersides of her bare tits were in full, obvious view.
(E-eh...)
She let her arms drop and tucked one leg beneath her casually again.
"It’s only that I worry about you," she went on. "You give so much of yourself away to people who don’t deserve it, Ethan. Someone has to say it. You’d run yourself ragged for any woman who smiled at you for more than five seconds."
"That’s not how things usually go."
"Isn’t it?" She tilted her head.
"Come on," she continued and shifted forward onto her knees on the cushion closer to him. "Look at me."
He looked at her.
Her piercing eyes didn’t falter.
"You know what I can’t get over?" She murmured, swinging a leg across his lap, "You didn’t have to. And that’s the thing with you men: always hungry. Never satiated, always looking for more."
"You never appreciate what you have, you men."
"Until it’s gone," she emphasized.
Her hands settled on his shoulders, and she let the words hang there between them, giving him plenty of time to feel their weight.
"I’m only saying this because I care," she added, in a voice so gentle it was almost insulting. "Someone ought to be honest with you. You had a whole house of women waiting for you, Ethan. Women who adore you. And you still went on and gave your afternoon to a woman who laminated name tags."
"Are we mocking dead people now?"
"Mock? No. Whatever she did. Poor thing." Nicole sighed and shook her head, and her hips shifted lazily against his lap. "You know, I keep picturing her face when she opened the door. She probably thought she was special. Poor girl, she never knew you fucked half the city before her, hm?. She probably slept with butterflies in her stomach, and all fluttered, thinking she may have found some true love for once. Did you check on her when you returned home, Eeeethan?"
"I-I was going to call her."
"Were you?" She raised one eyebrow. "Well, now you can’t. So that’s one less awkward conversation, isn’t it? God’s plan, I guess. Whoopsie doopsie."
(...?)
"Nic, that’s..."
"Dark? Yes. I know." She laughed. "You’re allowed to laugh, you know. She would have wanted you to. Probably. I never really spoke to her. But she wouldn’t want you mourning so long. So much for pleasing ddaaaddyy!"
(What a terrible thing to say...even for her.)
"A woman died, Nic. Do you hear yourself?"
"A woman died," she agreed, nodding solemnly. "And she died after the best afternoon of her life, so really, you should take some comfort in that. Go out on a high note, and all that." She sighed, as if she were truly considering it.
"It’s a shame, though. She had such a long future ahead of her."
She chose that moment to lean in and press her lips against the side of his neck, so softly it barely counted as a kiss, and every protest he had lined up went quietly out of his head.
"Shh," she murmured against his skin "you don’t have to think about that, though; never mind!"
"Nico—"
"What a terrible man you are, ethan cole." Her lips drifted lower, just under his jaw, and her breath came warm and slow against his pulse. "Yet, not everyone knows that...not everyone sees that, hm?. And if they did, would they still admire you? That would be weird!" she chuckled
Her fingers found the first button of his shirt and slipped it free. Then the second. She worked slowly, the way she did everything when she wanted him to notice. By the time she reached the last one, his breathing had grown noticeably uneven, and she smiled against his collarbone, probably at his lack of resistance, even at this moment, even now.
"There," she said, spreading the shirt open and running her palms over the muscle underneath his chest. "Much better, breathe..."